Throughout history, music has often been a deeply personal and cultural expression—something many musicians feel a sense of ownership over. This connection is especially strong among those who have dedicated years to honing their craft. However, musical evolution has consistently challenged traditional ideas of ownership and authenticity.
In the 1960s, the music world experienced a major shift. The rise of electronic instruments and emerging musical groups began to overshadow the dominance of orchestras and big bands. For many classically trained musicians, this was a moment of discomfort. They saw their established form of artistry being displaced by new styles, sounds, and technologies. Some criticized these innovations, claiming they weren’t “real music,” but rather just noise.
This pattern isn’t unique to the 1960s. Each time a new genre or form of music arises—from jazz and rock to hip-hop and EDM—it’s met with skepticism. Critics often question its legitimacy, its artistry, and its place in the musical canon. Yet, time and again, these forms prove their worth, shaping culture and expanding the boundaries of what music can be.
Today, we are witnessing a similar moment with the emergence of AI-generated music. Just like previous innovations, AI is being met with a mix of fascination and resistance. Many musicians are expressing concern, frustration, and even hostility toward this new method of music creation. Some argue that it lacks soul, that it’s not the product of genuine human emotion, or that it threatens the livelihood of working artists.
But it’s important to understand how AI music actually works. AI does not spontaneously generate songs out of thin air—it requires human input in the form of prompts. The more thoughtful, detailed, and creative the prompt, the more nuanced and compelling the resulting music can be. In this way, AI is not replacing human creativity—it’s reshaping how we engage with it. It’s a tool, much like the electric guitar or synthesizer once was, capable of opening new doors for expression.
Music has always belonged to everyone, both individually and collectively. It’s a shared cultural resource that grows richer as more voices, styles, and technologies are added to the mix. While some established artists may feel displaced or threatened by this change, it’s worth remembering that innovation has always been part of music’s story.
The key isn’t to resist the future but to shape it. Just as past generations learned to embrace new instruments and genres, today’s musicians can explore how AI can enhance, inspire, and even collaborate with their creativity. Rather than viewing AI as a rival, it might be more productive to see it as a new kind of bandmate—one that responds not with emotion, but with possibilities.